Stock markets buckle from Paris to Mumbai under stress of election results

Elections have consequences for financial markets. But what that means for investors is often hard to predict.

Just look at France, where the threat of electoral losses for the president’s centrist party recently sent the French stock market to its worst week in more than two years. Or India, where questions about the margin of victory for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s party sent Indian stocks from a gain of 3.4 per cent to a plunge of 5.7 per cent and back to a gain of 3.2 per cent over a wild three-day span this month.

“Elections have consequences,” strategists at Morgan Stanley wrote in a recent report. “But when it comes to identifying those consequences for financial markets, it’s easy to mistake noise for signal.”

Around the world, from Mexico to South Africa, surprising election results have rocked markets recently. And more is likely to come, with over half the world’s population heading to the polls throughout 2024, according to BlackRock Investment Institute.

Approaching soon is July’s election in the United Kingdom. Later this year, the United States’ presidential election in November will unleash its own volatility on markets. It all adds up to a lot of uncertainty for financial markets that notoriously hate it.

The biggest aftershocks have shaken countries’ stock markets, but it is in the traditionally sleepier bond market where the larger threat may lie. That is because many of this year’s surprise wins are leading to speculation that the victors may push for more spending by governments, without raising more in revenue to pay for it.

Looser fiscal policies could make it more difficult for governments to repay their debts. Skittish investors are already punishing them by demanding fatter interest rates before lending to them.

“The bond market’s tolerance for fiscal profligacy is very low these days,” said Niladri ‘Neel’ Mukherjee, chief investment officer of TIAA Wealth Management.

In the upcoming US elections, the bond market could remain calm in a scenario where no party sweeps the White House and both chambers of Congress, Mukherjee said. But if one party wins control, making it easier to dictate fiscal policy, it could mean sharp jumps for US Treasury yields in the bond market. That in turn would make mortgages more expensive, increase the possibility of a recession and hurt stock prices.

“It’s exactly what’s on my mind,” Mukherjee said. “Not too many people are talking about the bond market and how it would react.”

Consider France. Coming into this week, bond investors were requiring 0.75 percentage points of extra yield to lend money to the French government for 10 years, versus a similar loan to the German government, which is seen as a safer bet. A week earlier, before surprise victories for far-right parties in European Parliament elections, investors were demanding just 0.48 percentage points of extra yield.

That may not sound like much, but it is a big deal in a bond market where investors are getting just 2.36 per cent in yield for lending money to the German government for 10 years.

One challenge for investors is the difficulty profiting from or protecting against electoral results. That is because financial markets are constantly shifting based on who is leading the poll. To get ahead of them, an investor would need enough clairvoyance to know what the surprise result is that markets are not anticipating.

A Republican win in November, for example, could make higher tariffs and broader restrictions on trade more likely, which could boost the fortunes of US manufacturers. But their stock prices would already be rising ahead of November whenever traders saw Republicans gaining in the polls. And even if an investor were to correctly guess a win by Republicans, in a scenario where the rest of the market was leaning otherwise, that investor would also need to know when those trade policies would take effect to make maximum profit. That is a lot of things to get right.

Rather than trying to game out what investments will do in the immediate aftermath of an election, many professional investors plan for what investments will be doing years from now.

In India, for example, Prime Minister Modi’s failure to win a clear majority could slow some of his economic reforms. But the world’s biggest country is still benefiting from a young population, according to strategists at BlackRock Investment Institute. It is also still benefiting from the long-term drive by companies to rewire their global supply chains after the pandemic showed the risks of overdependence on China.

Besides, the US stock market has historically tended to rise regardless of which party controls the White House.

AP