I am experiencing a love-hate relationship with AI-generated presentations. I believe that AI should be used as a supporting character rather than the main character. Yet increasingly, the latter appears to be the reality. Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate AI. In fact, I use it daily. However, I am becoming concerned about how it is being used to prepare presentations, particularly those generated almost entirely by prompts.
My concern is not simply about the presentations themselves, but what happens when people outsource the process of thinking, learning and developing their own understanding to AI.
The Hiring Experience
From time to time, candidates are required to complete assessments as a part of the selection process. Some candidates will submit these ‘beautiful’ Claude or ChatGPT presentations. Interestingly, other candidates for the same role are producing similar presentations because they used AI as well.
While visually the presentations may look polished, they often need further editing as they do not follow basic presentation principles. For example, they have too much text or images, which isn’t the intent of PowerPoint presentations. This in turn leads to challenges in the presentation itself, as these candidates tend to read from the slides. PowerPoint slides are meant to support the speaker, not replace them.
I also wonder whether relying too heavily on AI-generated presentations can unwittingly erode the confidence a presenter has in their own abilities. Instead of concentrating on what they bring to the table, they may become overly dependent on what AI has produced.
This is especially evident in the question and answer segment. Once some candidates are asked questions about the content in the presentation, they start to struggle. It raises questions about the time spent reviewing, understanding, and critically evaluating the AI output. It appears as though the thought process is “AI did it, so it must be good. AI did it, and I’m a good presenter, so I can just wing it.” Based on my observation, the presenters who take the time to go through the work tend to deliver stronger presentations. This issue doesn’t only impact the workplace; I am also seeing it in the university classroom, which is the precursor to the workplace.
The Classroom Experience
I teach students at both the undergraduate and graduate levels. I have recently observed students using Claude and ChatGPT to create their presentations and the speaking notes. Similar to job candidates, when one starts to ask questions about the content of the presentations, the presenters find it challenging to respond, even when the answers to the questions are right there on the slides. It appears the focus is on the quick win of efficiency rather than investing time in the quality of the presentation. At this stage of their development, the learning process matters just as much as the output.
I keep reminding my students that their foundational knowledge is what contributes to them having the best AI experience. The value isn’t just in what AI can produce but what they bring to the process. I believe this message holds true for professionals as well.
For my next cohort of students, I may need to revisit my AI use policy to establish clearer boundaries around AI-generated presentations.
The Value of Doing the Work
The benefits of knowing your work intimately are lost when one starts to depend on AI entirely. When we create presentations ourselves, it is more than transferring the information onto slides. It forces us to think through what matters, how ideas connect, and whether we are telling the story in the best way for our audience.
Some people may get away with complete AI presentations based on their presentation skills, their knowledge about the subject area or simply because no one questions them, especially in a speech. Please remember that AI is just a tool. While AI can improve efficiency by producing a presentation in minutes, this doesn’t negate the personal responsibility to truly take the time to review and understand what is being produced. After all, that is how we learn. There is something about creating or modifying your own slides even if you start with AI as your partner and inspiration.
Ultimately, the issue is not necessarily how much of the presentation AI creates, but whether the presenter has taken ownership of the content. AI assistance should not mean intellectual disengagement.
Making AI Your Presentation Partner
A few ways you can use AI as a partner include:
- Start with your own thinking before prompting AI.
- Let AI draft the outline and suggest approaches but retain ownership of your argument.
- Refine and edit the presentation deck until it reflects your thinking.
- Treat speaking notes provided as a starting point and build on them in your own words so you can speak without reading.
- Question what is produced to ascertain if the content is really aligned with what you want to say.
- Do not forget the basics of a good presentation, such as using visuals with purpose, keeping text minimal and letting slides support rather than speak for you.
Ask yourself this question: If my slides disappeared, could I explain my arguments and defend my recommendations?
Ethics and AI
A broader conversation is needed about responsible AI use, ethics and the importance of protecting one’s own foundational knowledge. I will save that fuller discussion for another time.
Nevertheless, for now, at the organisational level, consider implementing an AI policy if you do not have one. Offering introductory AI training may also be beneficial, as some employees may lack the knowledge to use these tools effectively. We may also need to adapt our approaches to how we assess presentations to protect authenticity. For example, give greater weight to the Q&A segment in a presentation, asking people to explain and defend their choices. We should also be more intentional about communicating expectations regarding AI use.
At the individual level, if we continue to nonchalantly delegate everything to AI, we are slowly but surely contributing to the erosion of our skill sets that took years to build. In particular, our ability to synthesise information, reason analytically, think critically, defend an argument, and engage in creativity.
In closing, use AI, but use it wisely. After all…
Are you the main character in your own work, or have you become the supporting cast?
Yolande Hylton is the Managing Director of Hylton Insights, an HR Consultancy Firm with a mandate to guide businesses from the transactional to the transformational HR realm, thereby enhancing individual and organisational performance. For inquiries or to learn more, you can reach out to yolande@hyltoninsights.com or visit www.hyltoninsights.com

3 days ago
4
English (US) ·