Plea Deal Deadline Looms as Prosecutors Push to Add New Video Evidence; Squash Fights to Have Case Dismissed

The high-stakes legal showdown between dancehall star Andrae “Squash” Whittaker and U.S. federal prosecutors is escalating, with both sides trading heavy legal fire ahead of a possible September trial. In the past week, prosecutors have moved to introduce explosive new video evidence allegedly showing the entertainer handling and firing a pink Glock pistol, while also pulling material from his phone that they claim ties him to multiple other firearms. They’re also targeting his artistry, seeking to use lyrics and scenes from his Shubout music video—where Squash is seen among people holding guns—as proof of a deeper connection to illegal weapons and devices that can convert them into automatic weapons.

According to the latest report aired via Nationwide News, at the heart of the case are accusations that Squash is more than just an entertainer. Prosecutors allege he is a leader within “6ix,” which they describe as a transnational criminal gang. But Squash’s defence team is pushing back hard, insisting that “6ix” is nothing more than the name of his dancehall label. His lawyers argue that bringing alleged gang links into the trial is an attempt to prejudice jurors, just like the use of his stage names “Squash” or “Six Boss” in open court.

The defence isn’t just contesting the narrative—they’re challenging the foundation of the prosecution’s case. In filings submitted Thursday, Squash’s attorneys asked the court to throw out all evidence and statements, arguing they stem from an illegal search during a February traffic stop in Miami. They plan to call co-arrestee Zidanne Prescott, who will testify that no traffic violations occurred prior to the stop, in an effort to undermine the justification for the arrest. They also want any mention of prior homicide discussions, Jamaican police intelligence labelling Squash as a known criminal, or any gang-related allegations barred from trial.

The federal case stems from charges of being an alien in possession of a firearm and unlawful possession of a machine gun, both serious offences under U.S. law. Prosecutors claim the phone evidence, music video content, and text messages—such as one requesting a “matic”—are critical in proving Squash’s pattern of possessing illegal weapons. “It’s not just one incident,” their filings suggest, “it’s a demonstrated behaviour over time.”

With a plea deal deadline set for August 26, the clock is ticking. If no agreement is reached, Whittaker v. United States will begin on September 2, setting the stage for a closely watched court battle that could test not only the boundaries of artistic expression in criminal trials but also the credibility of the prosecution’s evidence-gathering methods. For fans and critics alike, the next two weeks may determine whether the “Six Boss” beats the case—or faces the full weight of federal sentencing.

Share this post: on Twitter on Facebook