Ryan Bachoo
Lead Editor- Newsgathering
Small island developing states are resisting attempts to weaken references to the International Court of Justice’s (ICJ) climate change advisory opinion in the negotiating text at COP31, while maintaining that limiting global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius remains a non-negotiable priority.
Alliance of Small Island States (AOSIS) chair Ilana Seid says countries will have to fight to retain references to the landmark advisory opinion in the final outcome document, amid resistance from nations concerned about its potential legal implications.
Speaking on the sidelines of COP31 in T’rkiye, Seid said the advisory opinion was included in the current draft but faced opposition from countries seeking to keep what they consider political processes separate from the climate negotiations.
“I think we’ll see a lot of pushbacks. I think there are a lot of countries that are saying we need to keep those processes outside of this one. They’re political in nature. They don’t belong in here,” she said.
She suggested some countries were also concerned that the language in the opinion could eventually expose them to claims for damages.
“They’re going to be actively fighting that. And we have to see how successful we can be in putting it in the cover,” she said.
The ICJ issued its advisory opinion on climate change obligations in July 2025, clarifying the legal responsibilities of states under international law in addressing climate change and the consequences of failing to meet those obligations.
Meanwhile, Antigua and Barbuda’s Minister of Health, Wellness, Environment and Civil Service Affairs, Michael Joseph, said he remained optimistic that the final days of COP31 could produce significant outcomes for vulnerable countries.
Joseph said there were clear differences among negotiating blocs over what should be included in the final agreements, but Caricom and AOSIS were maintaining firm positions on key issues.
He identified the 1.5-degree Celsius temperature limit as a red line for small island developing states, arguing that the impacts of global warming were already being felt across the region.
“For us as Caricom and as AOSIS, we have also drawn our lines. We’ve indicated that for certain, 1.5 degrees Celsius is a hard line for us that we’re not prepared to move on because of the overshoot that we’ve already seen and the impacts that we’re currently feeling,” Joseph said.
The minister also pointed to discussions surrounding the electrification agenda and the 35 by 35 pledge, describing them as strategic opportunities to reduce dependence on fossil fuels.
He also described a meeting with the Turkish COP presidency as constructive, saying Caribbean representatives were able to raise concerns openly, despite differences of opinion.
Joseph’s comments come amid renewed debate over whether the world can still achieve the Paris Agreement’s 1.5-degree Celsius temperature goal.
But Joseph said abandoning the ambition would be particularly dangerous for small island states, which face disproportionate consequences from rising temperatures.
He argued that maintaining 1.5 degrees as a target was important to preventing even greater warming, pointing to the difference between projected temperature increases and the current trajectory.
“We say 1.5 because we understand that until we have a line, then the chance of overshoot is going to be significant,” he said.
Joseph warned that moving further away from the target could expose Caribbean countries to more intense and frequent hurricanes, extreme heat, coastal erosion and threats to livelihoods.
He said small island states would struggle to keep pace with the financial demands of responding to increasingly severe climate impacts.
“Our coastlines are going to erode. We’re going to have stronger and more frequent storms and hurricanes, and it doesn’t matter how much money it is that we throw at it. Our countries are never going to keep up with those impacts,” he said.
Despite what he described as growing pessimism surrounding the 1.5-degree goal, Joseph said Caricom and AOSIS would continue pushing for its inclusion in the international climate agenda.


12 hours ago
3
English (US) ·