“This Is So Offensive”: Jamaicans Divided Over Government’s Planned Hurricane Relief Concert Series

The Government of Jamaica’s newly announced “Jamaica Love” benefit concert series — intended to raise funds for national hurricane relief — has sparked a firestorm of online debate. While some citizens applaud the initiative as a positive way to unite the nation and attract international donations, others have blasted it as tone-deaf and “insensitive” given the country’s ongoing grief and recovery from Hurricane Melissa, which has so far claimed 28 lives locally.

The first concert is set for November 14 at the National Stadium Car Park, featuring some of Jamaica’s top reggae, dancehall acts and “friends of Jamaica” from abroad, according to Culture Minister Olivia “Babsy” Grange. But what was meant as a symbol of hope has quickly divided opinions. Social media platforms have since exploded with contrasting takes — some praising the effort, others questioning the timing and priorities.

“Great idea. Hopefully there’s an online option where we can pay and watch,” one user wrote, highlighting the potential for international participation. But others expressed outrage. “How can you people think about concerts when half of our people are missing or dead?” one commenter posted on X (formerly Twitter). Another user added, “This is so offensive. People are still sleeping in shelters, and she’s setting up a party.”

Many critics suggested that the concert series should be staged exclusively overseas to avoid burdening already struggling locals. “Persons in Kingston are already donating what they can and still have kids and bills to maintain,” one Instagram user noted. “Keep it international like you said. Jamaica is local.” Others called for “boots on the ground” instead of entertainment events, urging the government to prioritise rebuilding homes, restoring power, and reaching those in remote communities still cut off by flood damage.

Still, not everyone shares the pessimism. Supporters argue that music — one of Jamaica’s most powerful cultural exports — can serve as both therapy and a global fundraising tool. “If done right, this could raise millions and lift our spirits,” a Facebook user commented, echoing sentiments from those who see the event as a rallying point for national pride.

As emotions continue to run high, all eyes are on the government to clarify how the event will unfold, how funds will be managed, and whether proceeds will directly benefit displaced families. For now, “Jamaica Love” remains both a symbol of hope and a source of heated contention in a nation still finding its footing after disaster.